Do you know that? The month is drawing to a close, the forecast looks promising on paper — and yet only a fraction of the predicted deals actually end up on the credit side. An isolated case? Unfortunately not.

After hundreds of pipeline reviews with B2B companies of various sizes and industries, we at Scalantec have identified a clear pattern: Most sales pipelines are an optimistic pipe dream rather than a reliable forecast. And the frustrating thing about it: The same warning signs are overlooked over and over again.

The good news: Identifying and resolving these warning signs is not rocket science — it simply requires discipline and a systematic approach.

The 5 critical warning signs in every sales pipeline

Here are the five most important indicators we've identified that determine success or frustration in achieving your sales goals:

1. Unrealistic closing dates — the classic pipeline illusions

The warning sign: A noticeable number of deals in your pipeline have the same estimated closing date — typically the end of the month or quarter.

What is really behind it: This artificial accumulation of closing dates usually has little to do with the reality of the buying cycle. It reflects the pressure of the sales target rather than the actual buying behavior of your customers.

Real-world example: For one of our SaaS customers, 68% of all opportunities in CRM had the last day of the quarter as their planned closing date. The actual completion rate on those days? Just 11%.

The solution: Closing dates must match the actual deal phase and customer journey:

• Early stage deals: Completely refrain from a fixed closing date, instead work with phases and their average duration
• Mid Stage Deals: Set closing dates based on specific buying signals and documented statements from the customer
• Late Stage Deals: Only here do precise closing dates make sense — based on written commitments

Practical tip: Introduce weekly “closing date hygiene.” Every date that has been set without specific customer activity or feedback is systematically scrutinized.

2. Lack of follow-up activities — the secret pipeline killer

The warning sign: Opportunities without clearly defined, scheduled next steps in CRM.

What is really behind it: Without concrete next steps, deals quickly lose momentum. They remain in the pipeline, but are barely actively pushed forward — and finally ship out.

Real-world example: During a pipeline review of a manufacturing company, we found that 42% of opportunities older than 30 days had no documented Next Steps. Of these deals, only 4% were won in the following three months.

The solution: Implement a strict rule: No customer contact without a defined follow-up activity with a clear deadline.

• Define typical “healthy” next steps for each phase
• Automate alerts for deals without recent Next Steps
• Carry out regular next-step quality checks: Is the planned activity really a step forward in the sales cycle?

Practical tip: Categorize Next Steps as “customer-driven” and “sales-driven.” Deals with predominantly customer-side Next Steps (e.g. “Customer presents internally”, “Customer sends feedback”) have a 2.5x higher probability of being closed.

3. Wildly varying deal sizes — when the pipeline becomes a surprise bag mix

The warning sign: Your pipeline contains deals that vary in size by a factor of 10 or more, but are still treated consistently.

What is really behind it: Different deal sizes require different sales approaches, resources, and time frames. If you treat a €2,000 deal the same way you treat a €200,000 deal, you're either making the small deal unnecessarily complex or making the big deal dangerously superficial.

Real-world example: A B2B SaaS provider had deals of between €3,000 and €180,000 in annual revenue in its pipeline. After segmenting and adapting the treatment of different deal sizes, the win rate for enterprise deals rose from 14% to 26%, while at the same time reducing the sales cycle for SMB customers by 38%.

The solution: Consistently segment your pipeline by market, product and, above all, deal size:

• Define clear thresholds for small, mid-market and enterprise deals
• Develop specific qualification criteria for each category
• Establish different SLAs and resource allocations per segment

Practical tip: Conduct separate pipeline reviews for different deal sizes. This prevents large deals from monopolizing attention or burdening small deals with unnecessary overhead.

4. Zombies in the pipeline — when the sales cycle becomes permanent

The warning sign: Deals that stay in the pipeline significantly longer than the average sales cycle without showing clear progress.

What is really behind it: These “undead” deals — too active to close but too inactive to move forward — aren't just distorting your forecasts. They also tie up valuable time and attention that would be better invested in more promising opportunities.

Real-world example: When analyzing an enterprise software pipeline, we discovered that 28% of all active opportunities had been in CRM longer than the average successful sales cycle + 50%. Of these zombie deals, just 3% were won in the following six months — but they blocked 22% of the total distribution capacity.

The solution: Establish consistent monitoring of deal age and activity frequency:

• Define clear maximum times for each sales phase
• Implement a “3-strike rule”: Three postponed meetings or deadlines without real progress lead to critical review
• Carry out quarterly pipeline adjustments — with clear criteria for when a deal should be reactivated or closed

Practical tip: Develop a “reclaim strategy” for zombie deals: A final, markedly different approach (e.g. direct involvement of management, significant new value prop) with a clear time limit. Then: consistent closing as a “lost” and transfer to a long-term nurturing strategy.

5. Inconsistent qualification — when gut feeling replaces the process

The warning sign: Your deals are rated according to different criteria, depending on the seller, customer, or current pressure at the end of the quarter.

What is really behind it: Without consistent qualification processes, your pipeline becomes a hodgepodge of subjective assessments instead of a reliable forecasting tool. This results in surprising losses of supposedly “secure” deals and inefficient resource allocation.

Real-world example: A B2B technology provider implemented MEDDPICC as a qualification framework and achieved 93% accuracy of its quarterly forecast — compared to an average deviation of 42% in the previous four quarters.

The solution: Choose a qualification framework (MEDDPICC, BANT, SPICED, etc.) and implement it consistently:

• Integrate qualification criteria directly into your CRM
• Make full qualification a prerequisite for the transition to late-stage phases
• Conduct regular sample reviews of qualification quality

Practical tip: For maximum effectiveness: Link the qualification directly to the customer's buying process. Each criterion should be able to be substantiated with specific customer actions or statements, not just the seller's assessment.

Beyond the individual warning signs: The systemic approach

This is perhaps the most important finding from our pipeline analyses: Most sales teams focus on 1-2 of these warning signs — typically on closing dates and deal qualification. However, real pipeline quality and reliable forecasts can only be achieved when all five factors are systematically addressed.

The reason for this lies in the interactions between the individual factors:

• Unrealistic closing dates lead to ineffective follow-up activities
• Missing follow-ups unnecessarily extend the sales cycle
• An extended sales cycle distorts qualification
• Poor qualification leads to wasted resources due to inadequate deal sizes

Breaking through these interactions requires a holistic approach to pipeline optimization.

Three concrete steps for a high-quality pipeline

Based on our experience with successful B2B sales teams, we recommend these three specific steps to sustainably improve your pipeline:

1. Implement a weekly pipeline hygiene check

Instead of just relying on the monthly pipeline review, introduce a short weekly hygiene check that addresses all five warning signs:

• Monday: 30-minute review of all deals without current Next Steps
• Wednesday: Control of all closing dates that are in the next 14 days
• Friday: Review of deals that have exceeded their typical sales cycle

2. Develop clear criteria for phase-to-phase transitions

Define precisely which conditions must be met so that a deal can move from one phase to the next:

• Link each stage to specific customer actions, not just seller activities
• Implement a “peer review” for the transition to late stages
• Automate alerts for deals that move through phases unusually quickly

3. Establish a monthly “Pipeline Truth Day”

Reserve one day a month for a relentless pipeline reality check:

• Identify and clean up zombie deals
• Critically question all deals that are supposed to close in the coming month
• Check the consistency of qualification across deals and sellers

Practical example: With this approach, a medium-sized software provider has increased its forecast accuracy from 62% to 89% within three months — and at the same time reduced the average sales cycle by 24 days.

Conclusion: Pipeline quality is not a coincidence, but a system

The reality of B2B sales has changed. In times of extended decision-making processes and more complex buying centers, it is no longer enough to manage the pipeline as you feel.

The good news is that you don't have to solve all problems at once. Start by systematically addressing one of the five warning signals, establish clear processes and then expand step by step.

At Scalantec, we have implemented exactly these pipeline optimization processes for numerous B2B companies — with remarkable results in terms of forecast accuracy, sales cycle length and, ultimately, revenue growth.

After all, a high-quality sales pipeline is more than just a reporting tool — it is a strategic competitive advantage.

What is the score of your pipeline? Which of the five warning signs do you recognize in your sales process? Arrange a non-binding conversation with us to take a look at your specific situation together.

‍

Moritz Heininger is co-founder of Scalantec. He has extensive experience in strategic consulting and managing global tech companies. Moritz previously worked as Managing Director at Tink Labs (Softbank Venture), Chief Operating Officer at Anchanto (e-commerce SaaS), Managing Director at foodpanda (Rocket Internet) and founder of DIDIT (VC-financed payment company). His expertise in application-related AI solutions and strategic business management helps Scalantec customers transform their go-to-market strategies.

‍